Darkness Made Visible versus the Best Books in Blood

     Both argument prose a good viewpoint that looks to aid children and young adult readers in their mental health, at the end of the day I feel this is an argument on mental health more so than anything else. My biggest issue with Meghan Cox's argument is that i'm not entirely sure what she wants. I think an ok metaphor for what happened here is a woman went to a grocery store and saw nothing but unhealthy food. Its a little bit ridiculous if you ask me i'm sure the carrots where just around the corner but next to the cupcakes those carrots don't look so good do they. Coming back to my initial question, what exactly does Meghan Cox want out of here argument because I must've missed it. Does she want these books to be thrown out, banned, not marketed towards kids, censored? She raises a good question ill give her that much. The question of how do books effect our mental health and how to the effect us in our development is a great question. Based on what I know about the benefits reading has on your brain if you write anything to get these kids reading, anything at all.  If you get these kids to read rather than watch videos, play video games, tv shows, scroll through their phones, etc. you are a saint and you shouldn't be too influenced by someone like Meghan Cox who wants the world to be how she dreams it could be, because while I'm sure its a nice dream its not what's real. You have no right to tell people what they should and shouldn't write about these books aren't going to ruin the world, smothering things in a yellow gold blanket to hide their life just might.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Class Canon and Cancel Culture

     This is such a tough discussion because it requires us to try and picture the perfect society. What to we keep and what do we get rid of to reach this utopia of ideas and learning.    “When you teach works like Woody Allen’s you’re normalizing and romanticizing the culture of abuse he was part of,” I can see this being true only in the scenario that after viewing Woodys work you think mimicking his decisions will be what improves for work to his  standard. I think media gives us too much information on peoples lives, and I think if great world leaders acted more like the wizard of oz and kept everything behind a veil we'd see kids that felt more inspired to live out their own stories instead of comparing significant events in their lives they'd compare the work they are creating. Now I don't think acts of violence and the sort should go completely unnoticed but I do think its important that we...
Read more

The Girl Who Drank The Moon

[Spoiler Alert]      Kelly Barnhill's children and young adult novel The Girl Who Drank The Moon.  Is a strong coming of age story about Luna,  a young girl left out in the woods as an infant. Luna is taken in by a Witch who accidentally feed her magic, as a result Luna is en-magicked. Throughout the novel the theme of sorrow is repeated over and over. Xan, the witch in the story constantly repeats to herself and others that sorrow is dangerous, stay away from sorrow. As it turns out Xan too was discovered in the words as an infant and brought to a castle of magicians who en-magicked her. As a young girl she is taught the message that sorrow is dangerous. I think this idea of sorrow in the book plays on the idea that sorrow can drown you into a world of hopelessness where you give up and don't seek to fix what's been done or what's happening. Luna mother referred to as the madwoman never gives up, she is locked away and her baby was stolen from her. Filled to th...
Read more

For Kelly Barnhill

 Dear Kelly,     I have been reading your splendid book The Girl Who Drank the Moon. I find it so fascinating that despite the age of Xan and Glerk these characters I feel can really connect with young mothers. There is so much to be learned from the beauty of these character. It is a story that asks to look inward for what is love, and all things beautiful. I really do believe that this story could be like a beacon of light for many young mothers in todays world.  My name is Lane Oberg, I am a young animator and feel inspired to create a short pilot to push this story being brought to a new audience through the power of visual story telling. Such a story should be told in full color. My plan for the animated plot is to focus on some key points in the first half of the novel. I say we kick it off with Xan discovering Luna lying in the woods. This will keep the mystery of whether or not the which is god or evil in the start. Next I will include some carefully stylized...
Read more